The Not Live from NAB blog

I really wanted to go this year and had pencilled in a trip taking my son Alex.  In the end, it was just not to be and we only got as far as London for BVE.  BVE is a good show but it doesn't have the international draw that NAB does.​  One of the big attraction of NAB is getting meet people who otherwise live only on the interwebs in Twitter, Facebook and blogs, not only from the US, but from across the world.

So whilst I promised myself I would stay at home and be productive, what I really do is get thoroughly ​distracted by every NAB tweet and post and slowly get dragged into Pacific Daylight Time.  If you missed all the excitement, then I recommend paying a visit to Newsshooter.com whose coverage really rocked this year.

So which have been the biggest distractions from the show for those not in Sin City.  This is my own personal top 5 in traditional reverse order:

​#5 Blackmagic DaVinci Resolve 10

​DaVinci Resolve 10

​DaVinci Resolve 10

Blackmagic Design have developed a real talent for the surprising over recent years.  Any suspicion that these are merely headline grabbing publicity stunts has been largely put to bed by a history of delivery (with a few notable exceptions) and a real sense of purpose ​from their CEO Grant Petty.

Resolve has been a consistent example of their philosophy.  Since they purchased DaVinci it has progressed from being a megabuck workstation solution through affordable Mac tower solution to free laptop solution in its Light form.  This would be understandable if Blackmagic were letting development slide but they are still cranking out new versions.  Resolve 10 has two stand out features: a built in NLE and Live grading.  The cost for upgrading - free and the free light version gets most new features too.  Why Mr Petty, you are spoiling us.

#4 Freefly Movi

​Movi M10

​Movi M10

With a pre-NAB spotlight shone on them by Vincent Laforet, the Movi was sure to be a show hit.  Vincent at hinted at something "game changing" before he showed his Movi short.  "Game changer" is such a loaded term these days that everyone knew Vincent would not use it lightly.  I got the impression from the interwebs that many folks went through the same journey I did.  Phase 1 was guessing what this new thing was going to be.  Phase 2 was mild disappointment when it turned out to be a rig instead of a 4K hover car for $1000.  Phase 3 was enjoying the video but not quite getting the significance.  Phase 4 was watching the BTS and say "Wow, thats so cool" a lot.  

Nothing I saw in the show demos and interviews has dislodged it from Sub Zero on an NAB Top Gear style Cool Wall.  It's not a game changer for me yet because I can't get close to justifying the $15k for the first model.  Rest assured I will be watching this area closely from now on.

#3 Convergent Design Odyssey 7Q

​I own an Sony FS700 which I would have had in this countdown a year ago.  Its usp is definitely its high speed modes but its main attraction was that it was a good all-rounder  for the money.  It fixed many of the flaws of the FS100 which is good but the feeling amongst my FS owning mates is no-one has quite nailed the picture profiles yet so that the FS100 still has a nicer look.  Another major difference of the FS700 over its little brother was that it was 4K ready.  Like many, I have a deep distrust of the word "ready" in a tech sense and this has not been helped by the trickle of vague information coming out of Sony.  Well, they have opened the sluices a bit and the we now know a lot more apart from the 2 critical bits of when and how much.  My mate Den Lennie has done a nice summary of what will be coming.  In terms of outputs we have got much more than we could have hoped.  Along with 4K, we are getting some arguably more useful 2K RAW options plus an unanticipated continuous high speed recording option.  The downside is the known cost of the Sony hardware required.  This isn't a surprise as much of it comes from Sony's very nice F5/55 line but the FS700 requires an additional interface unit. 

Convergent Design Odyssey 7Q

Convergent Design Odyssey 7Q

So this is where the 7Q enters into our story.  The Odyssey units are effectively a very nice monitor with a recorder built-in.  This is the opposite approach to my Ninja 2.  Convergent have announced a deal with Sony which will allow you to record both 2K and 4K from the FS700 onto the 7Q onto its twin SSD drives.  It doesn't exactly match the Sony solution exactly, but it is close enough for most for what we expect to be less wonga.  Convergent and Sony will still need to sort out their full pricing first before we will know the exact amount.​  As I need a field monitor, the 7Q is an attractive option.  It stings a bit that it is likely to cost more to upgrade than Blackmagic's new 4K for $4k production camera does outright but the FS700's merits are extended and enhanced.  Tony Reale from NextWaveDV recorded this great interview with Juan Martinez (Senior Product Manager) from Sony.  Sony's new found enthusiasm for supporting third parties is encouraging.  I think its clear that Sony understands that ending up with an FS700 that costs F5 money is pointless and they need to carry the fight to cameras like the Scarlet and 1DC by making alliances.

#2 DJI Phantom Gimbal

The DJI Phantom is not a new item having been high on my gadget lust list since Christmas.  The original standard GoPro mount made it the go to Cine Quadrocopter for those whose construction skills stopped at Lego (and not Technics either).  It was a great My First copter but the film clips were always a bit lacking.  The problem was rolling shutter effects caused by prop vibration and wind shear.  DJI's solution is to pair the Phantom with a downsized version of their Zenmuse stabilised gimbal.  DJI have specifically designed the gimbal for the Hero3 as it locks in like a GoPro backpack.  As well as smooth, jello free shots, you now get the ability to tilt the camera in the vertical axis from the remote. If you don't mind holding the Phantom and looking like a child playing with a Corgi copter, you can even use it as a budget Movi.  It is not necessary to make wumpa wumpa wumpa noises as you move it.

#1 Blackmagic Pocket Cinema Camera

Blackmagic hit us with, not one, but two new cameras at NAB2013.  Many would have chosen the 4K for $4K Production Camera as the star.  Not only is it stealing RED's abandoned tagline but it also brings the much requested S35 chip too.  If I didn't already have an FS700 I may well have made this number 1.  However, I do, so my 4K aspirations are headed in that direction.​

​"Properly small" I call that

​"Properly small" I call that

The Pocket Cinema Camera was the more surprising camera.  If you read my earlier posts you will know that I have an Micro Four Thirds system built round the Olympus OM-D EM-5.  I love shooting stills on the Oly, but a GH3 stomps all over it for video.​  I had considered getting a GH body, but it didn't really fit in with my nimbleness ethic.  I could have traded in the EM-5 for a GH3, but it doesn't have the same appeal as a stills camera.  So now in the Pocket we have a lightweight Olympus Pen sized body, supporting active MFT lenses and SD Cards with even better codecs and dynamic range than the GH3 offers.  Its not perfect - its 3x (to FF) crop is great for using classic S16 lenses (if you own any) but not so good using MFT, especially at the wide end.  It doesn't have the GH3's articulated screen, but it is usefully large and I am hopeful that, not being touch screen, it will be less mirror-like than its big brother's.  We also have not seen any footage but chief tester John Brawley reckons its very close to the BMCC.  It is still such a good companion for the EM5 that it has tempted me.

​Buttons rather than a touchscreen

​Buttons rather than a touchscreen

The original Cinema Camera has been the blot on Blackmagic's copy book in terms of delivery for well documented reasons.  Blackmagic have given us new delights before managing to deliver on last years.  Many folks are understandably hacked off about this.  I have a pre-order deposit bet on them having learned from this.  We shall see. ​

Is Sony Finally Listening?

In the HD-DSLR era Sony has tended to frustrate me.  Along with Panasonic they have the biggest profile in camcorders so had more to lose than Canon or Nikon.  Often quite good products would get hamstrung with what looked like marketing decisions.  The FS100 was one such product.  It always has been good value for a baby F3, closely matching its big brothers excellent image quality.  It even had a the benefit of 1080p50.  But there were downsides too.  Firstly Sony claimed to be addressing the drawbacks of HDDSLRs but they failed to include NDs like the competitor AF100.  It also wasn’t a global camera - Sony has since promised firmware but it was recently delayed.  I know a few people who own them and most love the image quality but criticise the handling. 

So when the first news of the FS700 broke I was skeptical, in fact I thought it may be an April Fool’s wind-up.  Not all the details are in yet and there is still time for Sony to stick a spanner in the works but I must say it looks really promising in the blurb: 

4K-ready

The first 4K-ready Super35mm camcorder in its class – providing an assured upgrade path to 4K acquisition and delivery - with full HD 1080p for today.The camcorder will also have the capability to produce 4K RAW 3G-SDI output via a future upgrade.

Whether you need 4K or not, its nice to have the option.  That option is going to depend when a compatible recorder turns up.  This is unlikely to be inexpensive.  If the FS100 was the baby F3 could the FS700 be the baby F65?  Of more immediate benefit is the addition of the SDI port.  The FS100 had only the much maligned HDMI port.  Thats one AF100 advantage cancelled out.

Super slow motion at 10x at full HD or 40x at lower resolutions

Incredible super slow motion capability of up to 10x slow motion at full HD resolution or up to 40x slow motion at a reduced resolution, giving you creative options that were once only available with specialist high-end equipment.

1080p high frame rates has eluded the budget sector.  The FS100 was already one of the best options.  OK, there are restrictions on shot length and super high rates bring various levels of compression but this is new and cool.  Its the closest thing to a baby Phantom.

E-mount interchangeable lenses offer a wide choice of lenses

The E-mount interchangeable lens system utilises an extremely short flange back distance allowing you to use a huge array of lenses via a range of adaptors giving you almost unlimited creative options.

Additional A-mount lenses available

The Sony LA-EA2 A-mount lens adaptor allows you to use the wide range of high quality alpha lenses and take advantage of the auto focus function for quicker, more convenient operation.

The FS100 has always been flexible in its mount options, even a few 3rd party Canon options are starting to appear.  The new adapter is probably overkill unless you have a strong need for AF.

Built-in ND filters

The NEX-FS700E features built-in, ultra-thin ND filters, offering exceptional shallow depth-of-field on highlights. It also means less accessories to manage as no external ND filters are required.

3G-SDI interface and HDMI

A 3G-SDI output enables easy integration with highest quality recording formats.

There goes the other AF100 advantage and a opens a clear advantage over HD-DSLRs.  We are starting to see HDMI output on the Nikons but its still flawed and doesn’t seem to realise the gains the FS100 does.  Presuming both these output are live simultaneously that opens a lot of new configuration and recorder options.

Exceptional ergonomics

The NEX-FS700E has a refined ergonomic design with a robust detachable handle and grip.

The key is the word “refined”.  I don’t think the FS700 will suddenly be a lot less fiddly than the FS100 and the “toilet-roll” EVF is still there, but early users say the build quality has improved and the accessories work better.

Switchable 50 Hz and 60 Hz shooting

The NEX-FS700E is switchable between 50 Hz and 60Hz to allow 24p shooting in PAL areas and no PAL/NTSC limitations.

Sony has listened, no waiting for firmware or having to buy two if you travel.

Selectable magnification and positioning of expanded focus

Expanded focus improvement allowing 4x and 8x magnification and a moveable area of expansion for easy focusing with shallow depth of field.

This should be familiar to those with Canon DSLRs, I wonder if it will work while recording?

Camera profile settings storage on memory card

Up to 99 camera profile settings can be stored, allowing rapid adaptation to multiple shooting environments without time wasted adjusting parameters. Settings are also easily shared in multi-camera productions.

Sounds sensible and opens up the possibility of easily adding new profiles.  One open question is S-Log, are Sony brave enough to bring that down to the FS700 and risk F3 sales?

Perhaps the biggest surprise is the price.  At a time when Canon seems to be determined to bump its prices up the FS700 comes in at £7200 inc VAT pre-order.  That’s more than the FS100 (£4700 inc VAT) but not a massive amount given the increase in spec.  Its a lot less than the C300EF & Sony F3 which are £12,000.  Its not significantly more that the Nikon D4 or Canon 1Dx (both about £5200 inc VAT) whose only real video advantage is being full frame.  The 5D Mk3 and D800 have a significant price advantage (sub £3,000) and are true convergent devices but the FS700 is a significantly better specified video camera which is suited to a much wider role. 

In fact its only significant weakness is the inbuilt codec.  Sony has a good track record in making the best of AVCHD with really good encoders but it is still what holds it back from being in the C300/F3/Scarlet club.  Still you can buy an encoder and a heap of nice glass for the price difference. 

My mate Den Lennie has already been shooting with one so I am guessing we will get to see the results from Den and others when NAB opens.